Miscarriage of Justice

This is the historic courthouse in St. Louis, Missouri where the landmark Dred Scott vs Sandford trials were first held.

In the 1830s an army surgeon named Dr. John Emerson purchased a slave while in the southern slave-holding states. He took his slave with him to the army base in Illinois where he was stationed, then to his next post in Wisconsin.

For five years Dr. Emerson lived on these army bases, as did his slave, Dred Scott. Since Illinois and Wisconsin were free states Dred could have claimed his freedom at any time, but he did not. Whether Dred realized he could claim his freedom or not is unknown.

What is known is that Dr. Emerson eventually settled his slaves in St. Louis Missouri, a slave-holding state, where they lived until he died. Dr. Emerson’s widow would not allow Dred Scott to purchase his freedom from her, so he sued for his freedom, claiming he should have been free during his time in Illinois and Wisconsin.

What happened next is one of the great miscarriages of justice in the USA, a despicable human rights violation which still makes the people of our country hang their heads in shame.

The Supreme Court ruled that Dred was property, and therefore did not have the rights granted to a citizen.

To quote Roger Taney, the Supreme Court judge:
“A perpetual and impassable barrier was intended to be erected between the white race and the one which they had reduced to slavery.”

This ruling had huge ripple effects throughout the USA, and had the consequence of striking down the Missouri Compromise (thereby shifting the stalemate which had happened between the non-slave and slave-holding states).

This directly led to our civil war.

This courthouse is now a national landmark, a lasting reminder of our country’s shame so that we may never forget it and never repeat it.