Night Watch

“ConaLee, there is no forever. We are on our walk and the day is fine. You must think…each day is separate, until a way is clear.”

Jayne Anne Phillips, Night Watch, 2023

///

Night Watch is a sad book for sad times, and one I did not particularly like. It won the 2024 Pulitzer for best fiction.

In the fallout of the American Civil War, minds and bodies are broken. And despicable people are prowling the frontier.

ConaLee and her mother, a young widow whose husband enlisted for the union, eeks out a living on a forlorn mountain ridge in West Virginia. Not safe even there from the ravages of war, they endure years of sexual assault and psychological trauma under the abuse of an escaped confederate prisoner who claims them and their cabin.

After ConaLee’s mother has been reduced to a catatonic state, their abuser abandons them to the lunatic asylum, where ConaLee grows into the role of nurse and her mother slowly recovers.

It’s been awhile since I read a book I disliked as much as this one.

While ConaLee’s harrowing plight evoked deep empathy, the author’s portrayal of mental illness within the asylum felt unconvincing, and the abuser’s descent into madness lacked depth and explanation. Her mother’s recovery, likewise, lacked nuance and was overly tidy.

Though the book contained well-researched insights into novel psychological recovery methods from the Civil War era, the characters and narrative felt disappointingly flat and plodding. It’s rare I dislike a Pulitzer winner; this one was a dud for me.